| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
| $30 | Jay Trautwein | Sage Schmitt | 3’s |
| $30 | Nancy Cushing | Maya Amburgey | 3 |
| $30 | Kim Washle | Hunter Thompson | 1 |
| $30 | Lauren Young | Hunter Thompson | 1 |
| $30 | Julie Ott | Mason Ott | K |
| $30 | Matt Vessel | Nathaniel Sims | K |
| $30 | Erica Swanks | Stella Vincent | 7 |
| $30 | Doug Schmitt | Calvin Heilman | 6 |
| $30 | Kristin Lally | Evie Larosa | 8 |
| $30 | Liz Taylor | Evelyn Taylor | 3’s |
| $30 | Kathy Bundy | Harriso Hoard | 3 |
| $30 | Will Washle | Hunter Thompson | 1 |
| $30 | Christopher Coppol | Gabriella Coppol | K |
| $30 | Michael Johnson | Harlan Bates | 7 |
| $30 | Caretta Price | Zoey Abner | K |
| $30 | Julie Ott | Mason Ott | K |
| $30 | Jim Towles | 6 | |
| $30 | Becky Morris | Hallie Morris | 1 |
| $30 | Linda Trautwein | Blakely Hayden | 6 |
| $30 | John Lally | Evie Larosa | 8 |
| $250 | Mark Steurer | Emma Steurer | 3’s |
| $500 | Jordan Case | Paige Austin | 5 |
April 2025
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| $30 | Debbie McBride | Elizabeth Earley | 7 |
| $30 | Jordan Eblen | Lucas Eblen | 2 |
| $30 | Joe Eberling | Lilah Eberling | K |
| $30 | Lynn Brumfield | Calin McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Gary Theiman | Brooke Bishop | 7 |
| $30 | David Young | Walton Simmons | 3 |
| $30 | Jessica Shaw | Banjamin Henson | 7 |
| $30 | Sue Heilman | Calvin Heilman | 6 |
| $30 | Ryan Fields | Jack Fields | 5 |
| $30 | Joan Jung | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Matt Thomas | Madeline Thomas | 4 |
| $30 | Patrick Murphy | Dorothy Mittel | PreK |
| $30 | Mira Nikic | Sofia Manjgafic | K |
| $30 | William King | Nanette Ridge | 6 |
| $30 | Betty Vance | Will Karrer | 6 |
| $30 | Lynn Coates | Matthew Lynch | 3 |
| $30 | Jinn Fuller Renfro | Tuezdae Schwiermann | 6 |
| $30 | Charlotte Shumway | Jack Schuble | K |
| $30 | Christopher Coppol | Marina Coppol | 2 |
| $30 | Jennifer Peterson | Melanie Brockman | 1 |
| $250 | Marsha Littlejohn | Jaxon Phelps | K |
March 2025
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| $30 | Sam Cahoe | ||
| $30 | Tony Montano | Mia Brutscher | K |
| $30 | Chris Givan | Emma Brown | 6 |
| $30 | Deb Bell | Liam Miller | K |
| $30 | Gary Theiman | Brooke Bishop | 7 |
| $30 | Crystal Cosson | Christian Duddy | 2 |
| $30 | Crystal Cosson | Christian Duddy | 2 |
| $30 | Joe Eberling | Lilah Eberling | K |
| $30 | Steve Jung | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Tony Forns | Alexa Amburgey | 1 |
| $30 | Becky Morris | Hallie Morris | 1 |
| $30 | Betty Holeman | Griffin Schneider | 5 |
| $30 | Andrew Pennington | Leah Gordon | 8 |
| $30 | Leigh Ann Degner | Ava Gravatte | PreK |
| $30 | Meredith Neal | Henry Kerger | K |
| $30 | Brenda McCulloch | Cal McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Matt Lindsey | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Matt Lindsey | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Mike Cushing | Maya Amburgey | 3 |
| $30 | Gary Passons | Corvin Passons | PreK |
| $250 | Mason Ploch | Mass Sales |
February 2025
| $30 | Sharon Schuler | Aria Frantz | JK |
| $30 | Erin Larosa | Evie Larosa | 8 |
| $30 | Deidre Holmes | Tuezdae Schwiermann | 6 |
| $30 | J. Andrew White | Tuezdae Schwiermann | 6 |
| $30 | Milissa Logsdon | Joanna Logsdon | 8 |
| $30 | Mike Quinn | Mia Vincent | 7 |
| $30 | Ryan Fields | Eli Fields | 5 |
| $30 | Charles Weiter | Lily Plamp | K |
| $30 | Robert Graves | Finn Bates | 4 |
| $30 | Ellie Blair | Lilah Eberling | K |
| $30 | Pat Ballard | Brooke Bishop | 7 |
| $30 | Tim Egan | Hudson Storer | K |
| $30 | Sarah Amback | Chase Amback | 3 |
| $30 | Tom Cushing | Sean O’Daniel | 3 |
| $30 | Matt Lindsey | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Dan Walter | Mass Sales | |
| $30 | Rob Fallahay | Jackson Adam | 5 |
| $30 | Joan Jung | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Emily Gregory | Henry Gregory | 4 |
| $30 | Meredith Degner | Ava Gravatte | PreK |
| $250 | Ed Chandler | Aymen Chandler | 5 |
January 2025
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
| $30 | Debbie McBride | Elizabeth Earley | 1 |
| $30 | Willie Weickel | Willie Weickel | JK |
| $30 | Cletus Klemenz | Tuezdae Schwiermann | 6 |
| $30 | Sarah Brown | Emma Brown | 6 |
| $30 | Christopher Coppol | Gabriella Coppol | K |
| $30 | Mary Margaret Young | Mass Sales | |
| $30 | Melissa Dobbs | Hannah Simon | 4 |
| $30 | Patti Noe | Caroline Jansen | 7 |
| $30 | Patrick Kersting | Thomas Kersting | K |
| $30 | Mary Bilyeu | Maverick Payne | K |
| $30 | Margaret Brooks | Jack Meyer | PreK |
| $30 | Betty Ramser | Sean O’Daniel | 3 |
| $30 | Logan Kilkelly | Nathaniel Sims | K |
| $30 | Joanie Lerman | Adeline Crutcher | K |
| $30 | Ryan Fields | Eli Fields | 5 |
| $30 | Nikki Frantz | Aria Frantz | JK |
| $30 | Becky Morris | Hallie Morris | 1 |
| $30 | Beth Beckham | Aymen Chandler | 5 |
| $30 | Rachel Just | Miehael Irwin | JK |
| $30 | Patty Luckett | Mass Sales | |
| $250 | Joyce Hall | William Karrer | 6 |
December 2024
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
| $30 | Joanie Lerman | Adeline Crutcher | K |
| $30 | Brad Haimbrock | Isaac Heimbrock | 2 |
| $30 | Cassie DeVito | Luke Gravatte | 1 |
| $30 | Cheryl Froula | Chase Amback | 3 |
| $30 | Bill Bradley | Bellamy Graybeal | 2 |
| $30 | Megan Peak | Mallory Simon | K |
| $30 | Kevin Strader | Harrison Norwood | 1 |
| $30 | Brian Dolle | Andrew Kersting | 3’s |
| $30 | Vickie Now | Ryan Dolle | 7 |
| $30 | Robert Horstman | Kenzie Neichter | JK |
| $30 | Toney Felker | Griffin Schneider | 5 |
| $30 | Werner Riesbeck | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Kristen Benner | Max Cornell | 8 |
| $30 | Erin McCulloch | Calin McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Louise Petro | Desbry Brown | 4 |
| $30 | Scott Gardner | Carson Taylor | JK |
| $30 | Matt Lindsey | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Meredith Degner | Luke Gravatte | 1 |
| $30 | Donna Jansen | Caroline Jansen | 7 |
| $30 | Margaret Weiter | Mass Sales | |
| $250 | Brittany Thompson | Hunter Thompson | 1 |
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
| $30 | Joanie Lerman | Adeline Crutcher | K |
| $30 | Brad Haimbrock | Isaac Heimbrock | 2 |
| $30 | Cassie DeVito | Luke Gravatte | 1 |
| $30 | Cheryl Froula | Chase Amback | 3 |
| $30 | Bill Bradley | Bellamy Graybeal | 2 |
| $30 | Megan Peak | Mallory Simon | K |
| $30 | Kevin Strader | Harrison Norwood | 1 |
| $30 | Brian Dolle | Andrew Kersting | 3’s |
| $30 | Vickie Now | Ryan Dolle | 7 |
| $30 | Robert Horstman | Kenzie Neichter | JK |
| $30 | Toney Felker | Griffin Schneider | 5 |
| $30 | Werner Riesbeck | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Kristen Benner | Max Cornell | 8 |
| $30 | Erin McCulloch | Calin McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Louise Petro | Desbry Brown | 4 |
| $30 | Scott Gardner | Carson Taylor | JK |
| $30 | Matt Lindsey | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Meredith Degner | Luke Gravatte | 1 |
| $30 | Donna Jansen | Caroline Jansen | 7 |
| $30 | Margaret Weiter | Mass Sales | |
| $250 | Brittany Thompson | Hunter Thompson | 1 |
October 2024
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
| $30 | John Eberling | Lilah Eberling | K |
| $30 | Lindsay Bilyeu | Liam Miller | K |
| $30 | Michelle Kirchner | Henry Welsh | 4 |
| $30 | Emily White | Calvin Heiman | 6 |
| $30 | Mark Wimsatt | Anna Jansen | 5 |
| $30 | Marie Lindsey | McKenna Lindsey | 8 |
| $30 | Harvey Barnes | Walt Simmons | 3 |
| $30 | Susie Schneider | Emily Simon | 2 |
| $30 | Caretta Price | Zoey Abner | K |
| $30 | Glenn Altman | Bethany Altman | K |
| $30 | Mike Lynch | Matthew Lynch | 3 |
| $30 | Ryan Fields | Eli Fields | 5 |
| $30 | Greg Knoerr | Griffin Schreider | 5 |
| $30 | Benita Hammons | Lucas Eblen | 2 |
| $30 | Ryan Fields | Jack Fields | 5 |
| $30 | Eric May | Kate Baines | 4 |
| $30 | Becky Morris | Hallie Morris | 1 |
| $30 | Mike & Diane Baer | Ella Amburgey | 6 |
| $30 | Tina Grote | Riley Grote | K |
| $30 | Mat & Maranda Sanderfer | Emily Sanderfer | 6 |
| $250 | Karen Hauber | Hannah Spencer | 7 |
| $30 | Nicole McGovern | Charlie Vega | K |
| $30 | Ryan Thomas | Isaac Heimbrock | 2 |
| $30 | Caroline Manjgafic | Sofia Manjgafic | K |
| $30 | David Schneidtmiller | Church Sales | |
| $30 | Joe Stovall | Adeline Crutcher | K |
| $30 | Morgan Brutscher | Mia Brutscher | K |
| $30 | Taylor Forns | Alexa Amburgey | 1 |
| $30 | Dave & Pam Murrer | Ben Altman | 3 |
| $30 | Robert Graves | Finn Bates | 4 |
| $30 | M Wakevich | Daniel Back | 1 |
| $30 | Shirley Brown | Libby Karrer | K |
| $30 | Janice Cornell | Collins & Callie Jo Cahoe | 5 |
| $30 | Mary Ware | Amos Chandler | 1 |
| $30 | Patsy Cox | Adeline Crutcher | K |
| $30 | Michelle Kirchner | Henry Welsh | 4 |
| $30 | Ashley Bean | Savannah Schickel | 2 |
| $30 | Andria Toon | Thomas Kersting | K |
| $30 | Benita Hammons | Lucas Eblen | 2 |
| $30 | Michelle Pratt | Cal McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Brad Bussatto | Ella Heitz | 2 |
| $250 | Carol Gardner | Benjamin Gardner | K |
August 2024
| Payout | Winner | Seller | Grade |
| $30 | Chad Spalding | Hudson Storer | K |
| $30 | James Knezevich | Lilah Everling | K |
| $30 | Erin McCulloch | Maggie McCulloch | 7 |
| $30 | Tim Fields | Jack Fields | 5 |
| $30 | Stephen Lusk | Georgia Lusk | 3 |
| $30 | Patrick Crush | Patrick A Crush | 3’s |
| $30 | Nancy Cushing | Ella Amburgey | 6 |
| $30 | Molly Payne | Maverick Payne | K |
| $30 | Emily Dolle | Thomas Kersting | K |
| $30 | Glenn Altman | Ben Altman | 3 |
| $30 | Lynn Brumfield | Calin McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Barbara Baron | Makayla Eblen | JK |
| $30 | Brenda McCulloch | Cal McCulloch | K |
| $30 | Toby Gwaltney | Brady Amback | K |
| $30 | Kris Horton | Elliott Horton | 7 |
| $30 | Delores Boyle | Ella Heitz | 2 |
| $30 | Dawn Miller | Nelly Goranflo | 1 |
| $30 | Daniel Hans | Church Sales | |
| $30 | Ashley Bean | Savannah Schickel | 2 |
| $30 | Bob Dawson | Savannah Schickel | 2 |
| $250 | Brittany Gravatte | Ava Gravatte | PK |